Got feedback on the new design? We're Listening! Send us Feedback

Gorecki's Symphony »

Posted by: Spadecaller 2 months, 3 weeks ago

37 CommentsReflectReport this Story

8.8

Scale of 1 to 10

Read: 16

Propped: 121

Comments: 37

Click Prop It to Raise Score
Prop it

Augmented by the artwork of Van Gogh, Hugues Merle, and Francis Louis Mora, this Spadecaller video dramatizes the dominant theme of Gorecki's masterpiece, Symphony No. 3, Op 36 (Symphony of Sorrowful Songs).

Read Full Story at youtube.com

Join the Discussion

+ Add Comment
Comments So Far: 37
  • 0%
    Spadecaller2 months, 3 weeks ago

    Thanks to Quakpot's pesonal recommendation, I created this video to accompany Gorecki's powerful arrangement as performed by soprano Dawn Upshaw and conductor, David Zinman. Hope you enjoy!

    Reply

    4 Replies

    • 0%
      quackpot2 months, 3 weeks ago

      Beautiful job, Spadecaller

      ----Songs of sorrow

      ----Messages of hope for humanity

      This is only one, very well-selected part of the symphony. People who like this selection might wish to hear Gorecki's entire symphony.

      Reply

      3 Replies

  • 0%
    rdy2rck2 months, 3 weeks ago

    Excellant.Sad and beautiful symphony and a very excellant job spade of the imagery. It blends the truth, some disturbing imagery and words yet signs of hope.A Plus 5.

    Reply
    • 0%
      TheRealizer2 months, 3 weeks ago

      Awesome Spade, stirs up images of ... "mans inhumanity to man".

      Reply
      • 0%
        SenorCoconut2 months, 3 weeks ago

        The music and imagery is beautifully combined, thanks SC

        Reply
        • 0%
          daducha2 months, 3 weeks ago

          OMG SC that was really moving.

          Reply
          • 0%
            engineer2 months, 3 weeks ago

            Awesome!! Really a tearjerker. Thanks SC

            People like hyperbola should see this

            Reply
            • 0%
              ML20072 months, 3 weeks ago

              At first, I thought you were referring to just your own son, and that he had gotten killed in the war, but then, I realized you were referring to all our sons who die in senseless wars or by genocide, the overwhelming loss magnified by never really knowing where your child is laid to rest. The torment and frightening thought of such for a mother must be unbearable, and as a father, I felt the agony of despair wrought from viewing the video. How much more for a mother? Yet, in the midst of despair, arising from the song was a certain element of hope. A timely piece, SC. Thanks for sharing.

              Reply
              • 0%
                Charlson2 months, 3 weeks ago

                Haunting and poignant. Very moving.

                Reply
                • 0%
                  BoxMonkey2 months, 3 weeks ago

                  Good pick SC . It's way to hard to watch it all , having spoken with some survivors of the Death Camps . I knew in the opening words what was to happen . Very bleak and saddening . The seperation of families . I can hear the childern screaming as well as the gas chamber victims .

                  Reply
                  • 0%
                    not2needy2 months, 3 weeks ago

                    More lovely than the last SC. thanks so much for sharing with us!

                    Reply
                    • 0%
                      Dicax_Maximus2 months, 3 weeks ago

                      I hate crying...........

                      11/10 SC !

                      Reply

                      1 Reply

                    • 0%
                      mmrhe2 months, 3 weeks ago

                      Wow....Nicely Done. Excellent use of music, poetry and art!

                      Reply
                      • 0%
                        Francisca2 months, 3 weeks ago

                        Sadder, more powerful, more moving, even more beautiful than usual! In one word: Imposing...Music and imagery perfectly associated! So am I, during a bref instant I thought you were referring to your own son( I do hope Adam is doing well). I loved Dawn Upshaw's performance!

                        Thanks Spadecaller!

                        Reply
                        • 0%
                          Spadecaller2 months, 3 weeks ago

                          I appreciate your comments and concern, but I want you all to know that Adam (my son) is home safe and is no longer in Iraq.

                          Reply

                          3 Replies

                          • 0%
                            texangelwings2 months, 3 weeks ago

                            Hey, SC, that is the best news I have heard all day! Tell your son that I am proud of him! Thanks for the news!

                            Reply
                            • 0%
                              Francisca2 months, 3 weeks ago

                              I would like to have such a good news every day, SC!! Thanks to God....

                              Reply
                              • 0%
                                Shadowolf2 months, 3 weeks ago

                                An old(sorta) swabbie just saluted your returned Veteran...

                                ...this has to be your most potent artistic offering yet...

                                Please convey my most grateful thanks for his service!!!

                                Reply
                              • 0%
                                icono12 months, 3 weeks ago

                                Great great production.

                                The music as well as the message is absolutely haunting.

                                Whilst perusing the Collected Poems(1956-1998)(ECCO Paperback publish 2008) of the Polish writer Zbigniew Herbert I found this prose-poem titled "Mother":

                                "He fell from her lap like a ball of yarn. He unwound himself in a hurry and beat it into the distance. She held onto the beginning of life. She wound it on a finger hospitable as a ring; she wished to shelter it. He rolled down steep slopes, sometimes labored up mountains. He came back all tangled up and didn't say a word. He will never return to the sweet throne of her lap. Her outspread arms glow in the dark like an old town."

                                I think the last two sentences say it all. No matter how the child is lost.

                                Thanks for the invite spade.

                                Reply
                                • 0%
                                  texangelwings2 months, 3 weeks ago

                                  The example of art and music at it's best. The results of the worst of humankind. Excellent choreography, that shines a light of hope that exists, by learning from the past!

                                  I cried with this and cry whenever I read or watch a movie that covers the horrors of Hitler!

                                  Thanks Spadecaller!

                                  Reply
                                  • 0%
                                    Spadecaller2 months, 3 weeks ago

                                    BTW... Tell me; do you think that is the lamest photo propeller's art editor could have found for this article?

                                    Sheesh...

                                    Reply

                                    2 Replies

                                    • 0%
                                      BronxBomber2 months, 3 weeks ago

                                      Under the circumstances?Mmm... yes!

                                      Reply
                                      • 0%
                                        blinkers2 months, 3 weeks ago

                                        Absolutely true, Spade. "Inappropriate" about sums it up.

                                        Reply
                                      • 0%
                                        Shadowolf2 months, 3 weeks ago

                                        ...their photo/story matching software HAS to be castoff drek from the DMV...

                                        Reply
                                        • 0%
                                          uncle-dave2 months, 3 weeks ago

                                          Nicely done SC. Glad your son is home and I hope has gets to stay home.

                                          Reply
                                          • 0%
                                            ETproductions2 months, 3 weeks ago

                                            What consummate evil hate-filled men can bring forth.

                                            My son will commission as an infantry officer this week. Knowing how pointless the Iraq war is, what it was really all about, I can only hope he is one of those who come back, and who come back whole.

                                            Reply

                                            5 Replies

                                            • 0%
                                              blinkers2 months, 3 weeks ago

                                              ET, let me echo your hopes for your son, sincerely. (I remember you mentioning that he was being sent to Iraq, a while ago).

                                              Reply

                                              4 Replies

                                          • 0%
                                            blinkers2 months, 3 weeks ago

                                            Spade, glad I had chance to comment on this thread, thanks indeed for the notice.

                                            This is such a heavy and poignant theme and it's almost impossible to add anything to all the fine sentiments expressed above. But I'll try.

                                            The somber (but beautiful) music and accompanying visual art & poetry exemplify just how high the human spirit can soar -- but at the same time, the dreadful images of the Auschwitz-Birkenau extermination camp portray the absolute lowest depths to which humans can sink. It is a memorable juxtaposition.

                                            (The composer, Gorecki, would've been in his mid to late teens when this hell-hole was operating at full capacity --his birthplace was only 20 miles away from those awful gates).

                                            Glad your son is back, and may you both stay well, always.

                                            Reply
                                            • 0%
                                              2sidestoeverything2 months, 3 weeks ago

                                              Heartbreaking and beautiful just as life can be. thanks SC you brought about great refection for me today.

                                              Reply

                                              You must be signed in to post a comment. Sign in »

                                              Submitted By:
                                              Spadecaller

                                              I'm an artist, poet, survivor, and a work in progress.

                                              Also submitted:

                                              Related Articles:

                                              Why not submit a story?

                                              Also Propping This Article

                                              view all »

                                              Groups Watching This

                                              No groups are watching this story. Why not share it with your group?

                                              Advertisement